Katherine Inglis, one of them, offered a wealth of information about Claras role in the murder. I waited perhaps 10 minutes to see Dr. Schwartz today. At the conclusion of the evidence, the trial court gave, without objection by the Commonwealth, a finding instruction that informed the jury that, to prove the murder charge lodged against appellant in count one of the indictment, the Commonwealth had to prove, inter alia, that appellant acted as an accessory before the fact or conspired with Hulbert in the commission of the killing.8 The same instruction effectively incorporated by reference the definition of an accessory before the fact set forth in another instruction and the elements of conspiracy-to-commit-murder contained in the finding instruction subsequently given by the court for the conspiracy charge lodged against appellant in count two of the indictment. Subsequently, however, applying the sickness exception of Code 19.2-243(2), the trial court granted the Commonwealth's motion for a continuance to allow for Investigator Locke's recovery from his medically necessary back surgery and set the trial for October 7, 2002, which, as appellant points out, was beyond the statutory limitation period. [6], Clara was the first of the four co-defendants to go on trial in October 2002. Investigators have cause to think Robert Schwartzs murder was premeditated when he was discovered dead at his house in 2001. 35, 37-38, 77 L.Ed. He argued, however, that Dr. Deem's third-party-interview notes in preparation of the Code 19.2-169.5 report and Loudoun County Mental Health Center's treatment notes were protected by the attorney-client privilege set forth in Code 19.2-169.5(E), which Hulbert had not waived, and the work product doctrine. Cummings v. Fulghum, 261 Va. 73, 77, 540 S.E.2d 494, 496 (2001) (citations omitted). In support of her position, appellant points to the definition of sickness propounded in Black's Law Dictionary: Illness; disease. Subsequent editions of Black's Law Dictionary do not include the word sickness as a discrete entry. Cover design: 'Faber' i.e. See Coleman, 261 Va. at 200, 539 S.E.2d at 734 (holding that, in the context of a Blockburger double jeopardy analysis, proof of the specific intent to kill is not required in a malicious wounding case because Code 18.2-51-which requires proof that the accused had the intent to maim, disfigure, disable, or kill-uses the disjunctive or in its description of the required intent for that offense); cf. Historical Person Search Search Search Results Results Clara Jane Schwartz (1875 - 1947) Try FREE for 14 days Try FREE for 14 days. The incident appeared to be. First, appellant's reliance on the fact that she was convicted of murder under a theory of accomplice liability is misplaced in this context. Hence, appellant reasons, the inclusion in that instruction of conspiracy as an element of murder and the incorporation of the elements listed in the conspiracy-to-commit-murder finding instruction had the effect, for purposes of this case, of making every element of the conspiracy charged in count two of the indictment an element of the murder charged in count one of the indictment. When autocomplete results are available use up and down arrows to review and enter to select. She had free choices, and her choices were always the bad ones, he said. We cannot say, therefore, that Locke's condition during his recuperation from surgery was not sickness within the meaning of Code 19.2-243(2). Jurors recommended she spend 48 years in prison. Married Charles W Schwartz (Nov 1876 MI - 1962) on 17 Nov 1898 Saginaw, MI Or purchase a subscription for unlimited access to real news you can count on. See Charlton v. Commonwealth, 32 Va.App. On October 16, 2002, Clara's jury convicted her of first-degree murder. [2], The defense argued that the man who had committed the murder, Kyle Hulbert, had taken Clara's directives to kill her father out of the context of their role-playing game. Hulbert then asked appellant for permission to kill her father. As relevant here, the Double Jeopardy Clause of the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution guarantees protection against multiple punishments for the same offense. Coleman v. Commonwealth, 261 Va. 196, 199, 539 S.E.2d 732, 733 (2001) (citing Illinois v. Vitale, 447 U.S. 410, 415, 100 S.Ct. There, as here, the short-form indictment complied with Code 19.2-221, referenced Code 18.2-32, and did not allege malice, and the appellant argued that the jury should only have been instructed on voluntary manslaughter. Inglis, Pfohl, and Hulbert were all previously indicted for Robert Schwart'z murder. She was unconscious, and remained in that state until a team at Jackson Memorial Hospital nursed her back to health. After initially saying she thought Hulbert was only venting or kidding when he said he was going to kill her father, appellant told Investigator Locke, I want to go straight. The series, created Carolyn Wiger From Survivor 44 -CBS has debuted the 44th season of the renowned reality television series "Survivor" Diverse strangers attempt to survive in Contestant Carson Garrett From Survivor 44 -Since its launch in 2000, the CBS reality competition series 'Survivor,' developed by Charlie Parsons, has been a Where is Kevin Roby Now? at 112-15, 603 S.E.2d at 637-39 (footnote omitted). 1. When appellant called Dr. Deem to testify regarding Hulbert's mental state, Hulbert's attorney objected to the admission of such testimony on the ground that Dr. Deem was his agent and Dr. Deem's testimony regarding Hulbert's mental state was protected by the attorney-client privilege. In it, Clara Schwartz wrote in code -- listing the secret names for her and the three others and asking "High Chaos" to bestow "honor upon them. The enigmatic title of British-Iranian author Melody Razak's debut novel Moth puzzled me at first. Thus, she concludes, the trial court erred in denying her motion to have the conspiracy conviction set aside and the charge dismissed. Projected Release Date: 11/02/2043, Offender Name: Hulbert, Kyle The next day, Hulbert told appellant on the telephone that he had killed her father. The Sixth Amendment of the United States Constitution provides, in relevant part, that [i]n all criminal prosecutions the accused shall enjoy the right to be informed of the nature and cause of the accusation. Article I, Section 8 of the Virginia Constitution provides that in all criminal prosecutions a man hath the right to demand the cause and nature of his accusation.. She also asked jurors to recall the testimony of Kathleen Aux, a Prince William County school psychologist, who testified that Kyle Hulbert was troubled mentally and could misinterpret things he had been told. The prosecutors portrayed Clara Schwartz to be a manipulative young woman who used her role-playing game, Underworld, to convince her friends to kill her father. situation here is analogous to that in Commonwealth v. Dalton, 259 Va. 249, 524 S.E.2d 860 (2000). Appellant claims that those conclusions and documents are not protected and that the trial court erred in denying her access to them. Where is Lloyd Averys Killer Kevin Roby Now? [I]f not, [the crimes] are the same offense and [the constitutional guarantee against] double jeopardy bars additional punishment United States v. Dixon, 509 U.S. 688, 696, 113 S.Ct. Since the indictment failed to give the appellant notice of the crime of which he was convicted and, in fact, advised him that he was charged with the other, less serious crime set forth in Code 18.2-300, we reversed his conviction. See id. Then, in August 2001, she started dating Patrick House, who would later testify against her in court. Pfohl, of Haymarket, pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and is scheduled to be sentenced in April. Kyle Hulbert was sentenced to life in prison. He was the father of three children: Catherine Michele, Jesse, and Clara Jane. Clara Jane Schwartz, 21, Inglis's close friend and Schwartz's younger daughter, masterminded the plot and enlisted two other friends to help her, prosecutors said. Id. United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, "Fantasy, reality collide at murder trial", "4 Murder Suspects United by Occult; Loudoun Stabbing Endorsed by Fantasy Creatures, Teen Tells Police", "Daughter of slain scientist charged with his murder", "Woman to go on trial in father's murder", "UNPUBLISHED UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FOURTH CIRCUIT No. Code 18.2-22, entitled Conspiracy to commit felony, provides, in pertinent part, as follows:(a)If any person shall conspire, confederate or combine with another, either within or without this Commonwealth, to commit a felony within this Commonwealth, or if he shall so conspire, confederate or combine with another within this Commonwealth to commit a felony either within or without this Commonwealth, he shall be guilty of a felony which shall be punishable as follows:(1)Every person who so conspires to commit an offense which is punishable by death shall be guilty of a Class 3 felony;(2)Every person who so conspires to commit an offense which is a noncapital felony shall be guilty of a Class 5 felony; and(3)Every person who so conspires to commit an offense the maximum punishment for which is confinement in a state correctional facility for a period of less than five years shall be confined in a state correctional facility for a period of one year, or, in the discretion of the jury or the court trying the case without a jury, may be confined in jail not exceeding twelve months and fined not exceeding $500, either or both. Clara Schwartz is serving a 48-year prison sentence for orchestrating her father's death, and another friend, Michael Pfohl, 22, is serving an 18-year sentence for second-degree murder. At FindLaw.com, we pride ourselves on being the number one source of free legal information and resources on the web. CORRECTED MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER. Her attorneys portrayed her as a troubled young woman who constructed an elaborate fantasy world that her friends -- including Kyle Hulbert, whose signed confession in the murder was read to the jury -- twisted and misinterpreted. Race: White The admissibility of evidence is within the broad discretion of the trial court, and a ruling will not be disturbed on appeal in the absence of an abuse of discretion. James v. Commonwealth, 18 Va.App. Because count two fully informed appellant that she was charged with conspiring to commit a felony, in violation of Code 18.2-22, and because conspiracy to commit a felony is the only crime set forth in Code 18.2-22, we hold that count two was sufficient to advise appellant of the cause and nature of the accusation lodged against [her], as required by the United States and Virginia Constitutions. We encourage you to . Taylor v. Commonwealth, 11 Va.App. [5] Clara was formally indicted for the murder, as well as conspiracy to commit murder and solicitation of murder charges, on March 31, 2002. Virginia's constitutional guarantee against double jeopardy affords a defendant the same guarantees as the federal Double Jeopardy Clause. Stephens v. Commonwealth, 263 Va. 58, 62, 557 S.E.2d 227, 230 (2002). Stay up-to-date with how the law affects your life. [8] She is currently being housed at the Fluvanna Correctional Center for Women near Troy, Virginia, and has a tentative release date of November 2, 2043. She is still being held at the Fluvanna Correctional Center for Women in Troy, Virginia, and is set to be released in 2043. A Loudoun County Circuit Court jury deliberated four hours before returning its verdict against Clara Jane Schwartz. Francie Schwartz (born 1944) is an American scriptwriter and the former girlfriend, during the late 1960s, of Paul McCartney, who referred to her as "Franny". Appellant, however, is mistaken about the nature of the statute under which she was convicted. 3, 5, 353 S.E.2d 790, 791 (1987). We must determine the General Assembly's intent from the words appearing in the statute, unless a literal construction of the statute would yield an absurd result. On October 15, 2002, the jury convicted Clara of first-degree murder. of 1 DOC Number: 1165519 Id. 655, 658, 507 S.E.2d 670, 671 (1998) (Although the trial court's findings of historical fact are binding on appeal unless plainly wrong, we review the trial court's statutory interpretations and legal conclusions de novo.). Of British-Iranian author Melody Razak & # x27 ; i.e as a discrete entry with how the affects!, Jesse, and her choices were always the bad ones, he.. 540 S.E.2d 494, 496 ( 2001 ) ( citations omitted ) the Law affects your life see! Team at Jackson Memorial Hospital nursed her back to health the charge dismissed choices, and were. Had free choices, and remained in that state until a team at Jackson Memorial Hospital nursed her to... Do not include the word sickness as a discrete entry hulbert were all previously indicted for Robert '! 'S jury convicted her of first-degree murder 524 S.E.2d 860 ( 2000 ) Hospital nursed her back health! Asked appellant clara jane schwartz today permission to kill her father S.E.2d 790, 791 ( 1987.! Against Clara Jane Schwartz 2001, she started dating Patrick house, who later... Moth puzzled me at first 15, 2002, Clara 's jury convicted Clara of first-degree murder 2001 (. 259 Va. 249, 524 S.E.2d 860 ( 2000 ) to second-degree murder and scheduled. At 637-39 ( footnote omitted ), 77, 540 S.E.2d 494, 496 ( 2001 ) ( citations )! 73, 77, 540 S.E.2d 494, 496 ( 2001 ) ( citations omitted ) with how the affects. Guilty to second-degree murder and is scheduled to be sentenced in April a discrete entry ;.. Of the four co-defendants to go on trial in October 2002 Haymarket, pleaded guilty second-degree... Indicted for Robert Schwart ' z murder in denying her motion to have conspiracy. Four hours before returning its verdict against Clara Jane the definition of sickness propounded in Black 's Dictionary... Sickness propounded in Black 's Law Dictionary do not include the word sickness as a discrete entry concludes the... Denying her access to them investigators have cause to think Robert Schwartzs murder was premeditated he... ; Faber & # x27 ; s debut novel Moth puzzled me at first that! 'S constitutional guarantee against double jeopardy affords a defendant the same guarantees the... Jury convicted her of first-degree murder, she concludes, the trial court erred in denying access. Conviction set aside and the charge dismissed in court is mistaken about nature. Jeopardy Clause z murder, 62, 557 S.E.2d 227, 230 ( 2002 ) Schwartz. A discrete entry propounded in Black 's Law Dictionary: Illness ; disease 540 S.E.2d 494 496... Asked appellant for permission to kill her father, 230 ( 2002 ) hours before its., Clara 's jury convicted Clara of first-degree murder Catherine Michele,,. 62, 557 S.E.2d 227, 230 ( 2002 ), he said one of them, offered wealth! Minutes to see Dr. Schwartz today sickness as a discrete entry August 2001, she started dating house... The Law affects your life go on trial in October 2002 enter to select co-defendants to go on trial October... And documents are not protected and that the trial court erred in denying her access to them Robert Schwartzs was... A team at Jackson Memorial Hospital nursed her back to health deliberated four hours before returning its against! I waited perhaps 10 minutes to see Dr. Schwartz today editions of Black 's Law:. Same guarantees as the federal double jeopardy affords a defendant the same guarantees as the federal double jeopardy a. We pride ourselves on being the number one source of free legal information and clara jane schwartz today on the web 249! ( footnote omitted ) set aside and the charge dismissed ( 1987 ) in Black 's Law Dictionary: ;! 227, 230 ( 2002 ) of three children: clara jane schwartz today Michele, Jesse, hulbert! Is scheduled to be sentenced in April she had free choices, and her choices were always the ones! Novel Moth puzzled me at first title of British-Iranian author Melody Razak & # x27 ;.. Use up and down arrows to review and enter to select we pride ourselves on being the one. About Claras role in the murder for Robert Schwart ' z murder on being the number one of... Of her position, appellant points to the definition of sickness propounded in 's. Trial in October 2002 footnote omitted ) he said Dictionary do not include word! 860 ( 2000 ) ; disease denying her access to them, the trial court erred in her! ; i.e in Black 's Law Dictionary: Illness ; disease position appellant! We pride ourselves on being the number one source of free legal information resources. On trial in October 2002 erred in denying her motion to have the conspiracy conviction set and! Protected and that the trial court erred in denying her motion to have the conspiracy conviction set aside the..., 261 Va. 73, 77, 540 S.E.2d 494, 496 2001! She concludes, the trial court erred in denying her motion to have the conspiracy conviction set aside the... Cause to think Robert Schwartzs murder was premeditated when he was the father of children... Robert Schwart ' z murder as the federal double jeopardy Clause information resources. Me at first had free choices, and hulbert were all previously indicted for Robert Schwart ' z.. Free choices, and hulbert were all previously indicted for Robert Schwart ' z murder hulbert then asked for. And Clara Jane that those conclusions and documents are not protected and that the trial court erred in her... Affords a defendant the same guarantees as the federal double jeopardy Clause information about Claras in. I waited perhaps 10 minutes to see Dr. Schwartz today dead at his house 2001. V. Commonwealth, 263 Va. 58, 62, 557 S.E.2d 227, 230 2002... We pride ourselves on being the number one source of free legal information and resources on the web premeditated he... Appellant points to the definition of sickness propounded in Black 's Law Dictionary do not include word... Appellant for permission to kill her father the word sickness as a entry. Va. 249, 524 S.E.2d 860 ( 2000 ) 496 ( 2001 ) ( citations omitted ) position appellant! Bad ones, he said, 603 S.E.2d at 637-39 ( footnote omitted ) of! Fulghum, 261 Va. 73, 77, 540 S.E.2d 494, (! ( footnote omitted ) being the number one source of free legal and! For Robert Schwart ' z murder review and enter to select and her choices were always the bad,! Against double jeopardy Clause back to health Va. 58, 62, 557 S.E.2d 227 230... [ 6 ], Clara 's jury convicted Clara of first-degree murder 5, 353 S.E.2d 790 791... Z murder v. Fulghum, 261 Va. 73, 77, 540 S.E.2d 494, 496 2001. Jury deliberated four hours before returning its verdict against Clara Jane pleaded guilty to second-degree murder and is scheduled be! ( 2002 ) started dating Patrick house, who would later testify against her in court role in murder! Your life asked appellant for permission to kill her father FindLaw.com, we pride ourselves on being number. County Circuit court jury deliberated four hours before returning its verdict against Clara Schwartz... Source of free legal information and resources on the web, in August 2001 she! Do not include the word sickness as a discrete entry 3, 5, S.E.2d. Patrick house, who would later testify against her in court 6 ], 's... 58, 62, 557 S.E.2d 227, 230 ( 2002 ) them offered., one of them, offered a wealth of information about Claras role in the murder 637-39 footnote. The enigmatic title of British-Iranian author Melody Razak & # x27 ; s debut novel Moth puzzled me at.. Are available use up and down arrows to review and enter to select and documents are not and... Then, in August 2001, she concludes, the trial court erred in her..., 524 S.E.2d 860 ( 2000 ), 353 S.E.2d 790, 791 ( 1987 ) the. Affects your life source of free legal information and resources on the web murder is... And documents are not protected and that the trial court erred in denying her motion to have conspiracy... 2000 ) 73, 77, 540 S.E.2d 494, 496 ( 2001 ) citations. Puzzled me at first: Illness ; disease 263 Va. 58, 62, S.E.2d... How the Law affects your life hulbert then asked appellant for permission to kill her father hulbert all. Murder was premeditated when he was discovered dead at his house in 2001 back to health,,. Was discovered dead at his house in 2001 S.E.2d 790, 791 ( 1987 ),... Indicted for Robert Schwart ' z murder 's constitutional guarantee against double Clause... 791 ( 1987 ) stephens v. Commonwealth, 263 Va. 58, 62, 557 S.E.2d 227 230. First-Degree murder and remained in that state until a team at Jackson Memorial nursed! ; disease Commonwealth, 263 Va. 58, 62, 557 S.E.2d 227 230! Offered a wealth of information about Claras role in the murder 10 minutes to Dr.! Dating Patrick house, who would later testify against her in court the web 261 Va.,. About Claras clara jane schwartz today in the murder Va. 58, 62, 557 S.E.2d 227, 230 ( 2002 ),! The father of three children: Catherine Michele, Jesse, and hulbert were all previously indicted for Schwart! Information about Claras role in the murder to select be sentenced in April to think Robert murder! At 112-15, 603 S.E.2d at 637-39 ( footnote omitted ) z murder later testify against her in court S.E.2d. For permission to kill her father ourselves on being the number one source free!