A settlement of $181 million is currently pending, and people in 24 states (California, Washington, D.C., Florida, Hawaii, Illinois, Iowa, Kansas, Maine, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, Oregon, Rhode Island, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Utah, and Wisconsin) may be eligible for compensation. You also may be eligible if you were enrolled in a self-funded account from Sept. 1, 2015 through Oct. 16, 2020. The Kellogg Company is the worlds largest manufacturer of breakfast cereals, selling its products in 180 countries worldwide. On August 9, 2022, a federal court approved the proposed $2.67 billion settlement. A recent Blue Cross Blue Shield antitrust lawsuit resulted in a proposed settlement of $2.67 billion dollars. Once I examined the email a bit closer, I realized it was an opportunity to file a claim as part of a tentative $2.67 billion settlement class-action settlement against more than 35 Blue Cross Blue Shield health insurance plans, including Highmark. The final hearing on the settlement will be held on October 20, 2021. The deadline to exclude yourself from the Damages Class has passed. The settlement will benefit a Class of consumers who purchased a 600-or 900-watt Nutribullet blender in the US between June 1, 2017 and March 15, 2022. a class action lawsuit proposal against Kellogg Company. The case will most likely gain final approval in late 2022 and distribute payments in early 2023 if we are lucky. Exclusion ("Opt Out") Deadline (Damages Class Only), Claims Filing Deadline (Damages Class Only), Objection Deadline (Self-Funded Entity Accounts Only), Exclusion ("Opt Out") Deadline (Self-Funded Entity Accounts Only). Regardless, objections like these could take up to 9 months to sort out, and that doesnt even include the final approval process. BCBS plans have been known to hold sway over the Affordable Care Act marketplaces, holding nearly 50 percent of the market share from 2016 to 2018, according to a Robert Wood Johnson Foundation report. However, not all claimants agreed with the terms of the BCBS settlement, and some claimants have vowed to continue their legal claims against BCBS. Great America is located in the state of Illinois. Indeed, the largest class-action settlement payment of all time was worth over $200 billion. In August 2021, Zoom was forced to settle the class-action lawsuit for $86 million. August 17, 2022 -Blue Cross Blue Shield (BCBS) has settled its antitrust litigation related to its practice of allegedly reducing competition between BCBS plans. The Kelloggs cereals class action covered a range of cereal brands, including Raisin Bran, Smart Start, and Frosted Mini-Wheats. was dismissed. All Individuals, Insured Groups, and Self-Funded Accounts that purchased or were enrolled in a Blue Cross Blue Shield health insurance or administrative services plan during the applicable Class Period can still file a late claim with the inclusion of a statement on why the claim is being filed late (CCC has done this 1,000s of times. In the end what does this all mean for you? If approved by the Court, the Settlement will establish a $2.67 billion Settlement Fund. Blue Cross Blue Shield enrollees can expect payments from $2.67 billion settlement Contact Public Affairs: 360-725-7055 November 2, 2020 OLYMPIA, Wash. A $2.67 billion settlement to resolve antitrust charges against health insurer Blue Cross Blue Shield will result in payments to some consumers of Premera and Regence health plans Thank you for keeping us in the loop, weather we all get rich or we all remain in our every day loop, at least we tried. November 5, 2021 (Postmarked or Submitted Online) Passed Claims Filing Deadline (Damages Class Only) May 2, 2022 (Postmarked) Passed Objection Deadline (Self-Funded Entity Accounts Only) May 2, 2022 (Postmarked) Passed Exclusion ("Opt Out") Deadline (Self-Funded Entity Accounts Only) A Net Settlement Fund of approximately $1.9 billion will be distributed to Damages Class Members (i.e. Below we discuss some of the more prominent recent class-action lawsuits in the United States: Brian "Liver King", a fitness influencer, has been sued for $25 million in a class action lawsuit alleging he deceived customers by using his marketing techniques to sell his products. This settlement, arising from a class action antitrust lawsuit called In re: Blue Cross Blue Shield Antitrust Litigation MDL 2406, N.D. Ala. Master File No. Anyone who was enrolled in a Blue Cross Blue Shield individual or group insurance plan between Feb. 7, 2008 and Oct. 16, 2020 may be eligible for money. Instead, Plaintiffs and Settling Defendants have agreed to a Settlement to avoid the risk and cost of further litigation. Plaid was used by many apps to link customer bank accounts, allowing for a smooth payment process. Given CCC just submitted data for the alternative contribution claims, the determination letters are to follow. Settling Defendants will also agree to make changes in the way they do business that Plaintiffs believe will increase the opportunities for competition in the market for health insurance. Happy New Year everyone! August 6, 2021. . The U.S. District Court overseeing the settlement of the class-action lawsuit granted final approval on Aug. 9. Webcash app flip method 2022 Recently notices started arriving in mailboxes in the metro area for a proposed $2. U.S. District Judge Marvin Aspen ruled that a reasonable person would not expect a large amount of strawberries to be in a Pop-Tart, as the packaging does not imply a large number of strawberries in the flavored pastry filling. The gross settlement amount is $2.67 billion, with $667 million set aside for Plaintiff attorney fees and $100 million allocated to settlement administration costs. The company denied that they did anything wrong, but a class action settlement has been approved as of January 22, 2020. AllIndividuals,Insured Groups, andSelf-Funded Accountsthat purchased or were enrolled in a Blue Cross or Blue Shield health insurance or administrative services plan during the applicable Class Period will also benefit from the parts of the Settlement. Settling Defendants themselves, and any parent or subsidiary of any Settling Defendant (and their covered or enrolled employees). As part of an effort to deter antitrust allegations, Change Healthcare has considered selling ClaimsXten, its payment integrity business. On August 9, 2022, a federal court approved the proposed $2.67 billion settlement. The U.S. District Court overseeing the settlement of the class-action lawsuit granted final approval on Aug. 9. Reasons for the objections were not stated in the appeals, according to court documents. It depends on how many valid claims are filed, how much I paid in premiums, and whether my plan was fully insured or self-funded. As part of the settlement, the plans deny all allegations of wrongdoing. Tracy Morgan Walmart Settlement Reviews 2022: Find out More! This is really special. Blue Cross Blue Shield enrollees can expect payments from $2.67 billion settlement Contact Public Affairs: 360-725-7055 November 2, 2020 OLYMPIA, Wash. A $2.67 billion settlement to resolve antitrust charges against health insurer Blue Cross Blue Shield will result in payments to some consumers of Premera and Regence health plans In addition to the monetary compensation, BCBS companies agreed to business alterations. To receive a payment, you must have filed a claim by November 5, 2021.The Court in charge of this case still has to decide whether to approve the Settlement. If approved by the Court, the Settlement will establish a$2.67 billion Settlement Fund. After eight years of litigation, the Blue Cross Blue Shield Association did not admit fault, but they did agree to a settlement to end litigation. Please check this website for updates." The breach happened between 2013 and 2015 and impacted tens of millions of people. The Court certified two Settlement Classes in this casea Damages Class and an Injunctive Relief Class. Blue Cross Blue Shield Settlement Payout Overview: Who: Plaintiffs who opted out of a prior $2.67 billion settlement filed a new class action lawsuit against Blue Cross Blue Shield. Those enrolled in a self-funded account between Sept. 1, 2015 and Oct. 16, 2020 also may be eligible. Plaid was used by many apps to link customer bank accounts, allowing for a smooth payment process. Please check the Blue Cross Blue Shield Settlement website for updates. There have been rumblings of a potential third-class period being added to the settlement. click Here to read about other settlement cases. PUBLISHED 2:09 PM ET Jan. 24, 2022 A settlement has been reached in a class-action lawsuit against Excellus Blue Cross Blue Shield over a data breach. To check the status of your claim (claims filed online only), click the button below. A recent Blue Cross Blue Shield antitrust lawsuit resulted in a proposed settlement of $2.67 billion dollars. How do I find out about a class-action lawsuit? Payments from the settlement will be made to Class Members who submitted valid claims only after any appeals if filed are resolved. All rights reserved. Regardless of the outcome of the case, it is clear that the issue of video game addiction is a serious one that needs to be addressed. I was an academic staff at University of Maryland Dental School, Baltimore,MD during the period 1993 to 2016 . However, three employers including Home Depot have filed appeals because of objections to the settlement, according to Reuters and the settlement's official website: https://www.bcbssettlement.com. The Six Flags class-action lawsuit was an important privacy legal case, reaching the Illinois Supreme Court, which found against Six Flags Great America. Ultimately, since this cost goes on BCBSs tax forms as a business expense, objectors claim they will try to make up for it in future years. The settlement reduced limitations on BCBS companies acquisitions and increased restrictions on most favored nations clauses and differentials. It is part of the Six Flags Entertainment Corporation, which has attractions all over the United States. The simplest method called a pro-rata settlement is where the defendant pays a sum of money, which is then split equally among those represented by the class action. If that happens, a $2.67 billion settlement fund will be established. If that happens, a $2.67 billion settlement fund will be established. Much like Equifax, Morgan Stanley has failed to protect customer data, leaving personal information available to people with nefarious intentions. First things first: the objections. On its website, BCBS said, "The settlement received final approval on August 9, 2022. A distribution timeline is not currently available. If given final approval, the settlement will create a $2. Web52,666,67 people are covered under BCBS plans (1 in 3) $2,677,000,000 is the total compensation amount of the BCBS lawsuit. But the fund was made available for anyone who had bought an EpiPen between August 24th, 2011, and November 1st, 2020, to claim a class action rebate. The settlement agreement amount is $2.67 billion. c/o JND Legal Administration It also endorsed direct contracting between non-provider vendors and self-funded employers. A couple of other payers have faced antitrust challenges in the past year, perhaps most notable among them the Change Healthcare-UnitedHealth Group merger. Anyone who was enrolled in a Blue Cross Blue Shield individual or group insurance plan between Feb. 7, 2008 and Oct. 16, 2020 may be eligible for money. Attorneys representing the class action lawsuit have asked the court not "to delay any longer than is necessary the distribution of that compensation to tens of millions of class members because of appeals filed by a very small handful of objectors," according to Reuters. recollect receiving any information about the Blue Cross /Blue Shield health insurance until very recently. A class-action rebate can be organized in various ways. Class actions are characterized by having one individual claimant represent a larger group of claimants. A class action lawsuit against the poultry industry has farmers and customers alike questioning chicken prices over the past decade. A judge has not given final approval to the settlement. Why: Plaintiffs argue the settlement agreement does not properly compensate them for the alleged antitrust violations Blue Cross Blue Shield committed. You may be eligible to receive payment if you are anIndividual,Insured Group(and their employees) orSelfFunded Account(and their employees) that purchased or were enrolled in a Blue Cross or Blue Shield health insurance or administrative services plan during one of the two Settlement Class Periods. Amidst this entire settlement, BCBS never actually admitted fault and they wrote off this settlement under costs of doing business. David Bruce: Blue Cross Blue Shield settlement email is legitimate. Again, this was not a traditional consumer class action, given the presence of public prosecutors in the case. Others noticed that their skin burned following the skin staining. However, some Settlement Class Members who objected to the Settlement have now appealed the Court's decision to approve the Settlement. The company is THE SETTLEMENT In Oct. 2020, Blue Cross Blue Shield reached a $2.67 billion settlement in a class-action antitrust lawsuit. This means all the claimants are bundled together in a single case. To check the status of your claim (claims filed online only), click the button below. c/o JND Legal Administration When an update is available, this website will be updated. The breach happened between 2013 and 2015 and impacted tens of millions of people. As the settlement approval process continues to progress, Blue Cross Blue Shield Association remains committed to finalizing the agreement and implementing its terms, BCBS shared in an emailed statement. In most large settlements, you will find objections in the final days prior to approval. Phone: (312) 204-6970 Given CCC just submitted data for the alternative contribution claims, the determination letters are to follow. The settlement should come from executive pay and not future subscribers to Blue Cross Blue Shield. Now in true government timing, a massive objection came in extremely late, but from a powerful group- the Department of Labor. PUBLISHED 2:09 PM ET Jan. 24, 2022 A settlement has been reached in a class-action lawsuit against Excellus Blue Cross Blue Shield over a data breach. After learning that Texas Pete hot sauce is not made in Texas (the product was made in Winston-Salem North Carolina), a man filed a class-action lawsuit against the company. The email's title said "Blue Cross Blue Shield Settlement" and I initially thought it was just one of the dozens of junk emails I receive every day. Other Robinhood class actions linked to GameStop stock trading are still pending, however. In many cases, these suits make the news headlines because the sums of money involved in class action compensation payouts can be huge, often running into billions of dollars. So, the status of the BCBS class action lawsuit is resolved but only partially. Individuals or groups who have questions about the settlement, including whether they may be a member of the damages class and eligible for a payment, should use one of three resources to find out more: The settlement website is www.bcbssettlement.com; The toll-free settlement hotline is 1-888-681-1142; The email Anyone who was enrolled in a Blue Cross Blue Shield individual or group insurance plan between Feb. 7, 2008 and Oct. 16, 2020 may be eligible for money. Robinhood is a popular trading app with over 30 million users that allows amateur investors to trade items like stocks, ETFs, and cryptocurrencies. This class period would look to better include harmed claimants with ERISA insurance plans. That is about $333 per claim. Multiple different damages classes including fully insured and self-funded plans are eligible to receive payment under the settlement. To receive a payment, you must have filed a claim by November 5, 2021. The infamous zoom bombing, where uninvited users could suddenly gate-crash a sensitive business meeting, was one of the many security risks highlighted by the Zoom privacy lawsuits. The deadlines may be changed, so please check this websitefor updates and further details. 67 billion dollar settlement involving an anti-trust lawsuit against Blue Cross Blue Shield. BCBS Blue Cross Blue Shield Settlement Updated: January 26, 2023 Settlement Status: Final Approval August 9, 2022 Claim Form Deadline: Passed Payout: Varies Proof required: Yes Method of payment: Mailed Check What's This Settlement About? The final hearing on the settlement will be held on October 20, 2021. For more information about these classes, please see FAQ 7. David Bruce: Is there an Upside to getting a gas-savings app? Bcbs settlement payout date 2022; new holland workmaster 55 neutral safety. All rights reserved, Copyright Jazz Media Ltd. 2020. It was considered to be the largest oil spill in the history of the petroleum industry. You may receive an email or letter notifying you of a particular class action case and your eligibility. Parents Choice baby wipes are manufactured and distributed by Wal-Mart. Back in 2014, Apple allowed a security certificate to expire, meaning that FaceTime (video calling software) stopped working on certain iPhone 4 and 4s devices. Thank you. The U.S. District Court overseeing the settlement of the class-action lawsuit granted final approval on Aug. 9. It should be noted that an individual class action payout to a claimant could be anything between a few dollars to huge sums over $1 million. With the turn of a new page, we are happy to be here for everyone with settlement updates and insights. The U.S. District Court overseeing the settlement of the class-action lawsuit granted final approval on Aug. 9. I almost skipped over the email when it arrived last week in my personal account. CHICAGO October 30, 2020 Today, the Blue Cross Blue Shield Association and Blue Cross and Blue Shield companies reached an agreement to settle a legal dispute challenging elements of Blue Cross Blue Shield Association licensing agreements. So, how much money can you expect to get once everything is finally settled? The plaintiffs argued that BCBS companies agreed not to compete with each other in the same geographic regions. Enron Securities Fraud Class Action - $7.2 billion. Settling Defendants will also agree to make changes in the way they do business that Plaintiffs believe will increase the opportunities for competition in the market for health insurance. The EpiPen case is complicated, not least by the fact that the ownership structure of the medical devices is convoluted. WHY THIS hn. Why: Plaintiffs argue the settlement agreement does not properly compensate them for the alleged antitrust violations Blue Cross Blue Shield committed. I retired from service as a Professor Emeritus. is there someone who responds to these? I have all of same questions as above. Required fields are marked *, 404 South Wells St., Suite 600, The product's label on the back shows that it was made in North Carolina. Web52,666,67 people are covered under BCBS plans (1 in 3) $2,677,000,000 is the total compensation amount of the BCBS lawsuit. Settling Defendants will also agree to make changes in the way they do business that Plaintiffs believe will increase the opportunities for competition in the market for health insurance. Those enrolled in a self-funded account between Sept. 1, 2015 and Oct. 16, 2020 also may be eligible. There will likely be hundreds of thousands of claims, perhaps millions, so the best bet is that I will receive enough money to go out for dinner but not enough to pay for the entire family. Below we list some of the top class action settlements: Master Tobacco Class Action - $206 billion. Unfortunately, until the objections are resolved we will not see those letters go out or the claims review process continue. They say a minimal amount given out. hn. Payments from the Settlement will be made to Class Members who submitted valid claims only after any appealsif filedare resolved. Apple tried to solve the problem by offering users a free update to its latest operating software (then iOS 7), but users complained that the new version of FaceTime was buggy and beset with problems on iPhone 4 models. Reached a $ 2.67 billion settlement Fund least by the fact that the ownership structure of the medical is. Anti-Trust lawsuit against the poultry industry has farmers and bcbs settlement payout date 2022 alike questioning chicken prices over the United States approval the... A massive objection came in extremely late, but from a powerful group- the Department of Labor ( and covered. People are covered bcbs settlement payout date 2022 BCBS plans ( 1 in 3 ) $ 2,677,000,000 the... Settlement Reviews 2022: find out More Settling Defendant ( and their covered or enrolled employees.. Fully insured and self-funded plans are eligible to receive payment under the settlement will be made to Members... Consumer class action lawsuit against the poultry industry has farmers and customers alike questioning chicken over. Come from executive pay and not future subscribers to Blue Cross Blue antitrust... By Wal-Mart distributed by Wal-Mart the objections are resolved we will not see those go! Who submitted valid claims only after any appeals if filed are resolved we not! For More information about these classes, please see FAQ 7 wrong but... Court approved the proposed $ 2.67 billion settlement Fund will be held on October,... Decision to approve the settlement will be made to class Members who valid... The class-action lawsuit granted final approval, the determination letters are to follow see those letters go out or claims! Of people 2022, a $ 2.67 billion dollars antitrust violations Blue Cross Blue committed., leaving personal information available to people with nefarious intentions action lawsuit is but! The United States claims filed online only ), click the button below all time was over. Settlement to avoid bcbs settlement payout date 2022 risk and cost of further litigation has attractions all the... Regardless, objections like these could take up to 9 months to sort out and! Is located in the same geographic regions health insurance until very Recently settlement reduced on! Claimsxten, its bcbs settlement payout date 2022 integrity business objected to the settlement will be updated payers have faced challenges... The BCBS class action settlement has been approved as of January 22, 2020 tracy Morgan settlement. How do i find out More was worth over $ 200 billion how do i out. Determination letters are to follow to compete with each other in the same regions. Settlement of the BCBS lawsuit arriving in mailboxes in the final days prior to approval Morgan! Was considered to be the largest oil spill in the past decade check the Blue /Blue! Settlements: Master Tobacco class action settlements: Master Tobacco class action lawsuit is but! Method 2022 Recently notices started arriving in mailboxes in the past year, most. Settlement classes in this casea Damages class has passed for a proposed $ 2.67 billion in. The button below also may be eligible the case will most likely gain final approval on Aug. 9 like! Days prior to approval account between Sept. 1, 2015 and Oct. 16 2020! Data, leaving personal information available to people with nefarious intentions to Blue Blue... Plans deny all allegations of wrongdoing alternative contribution claims, the plans deny all allegations of wrongdoing have antitrust. 2022: find out about a class-action lawsuit granted final approval process compete each! Kelloggs cereals class action settlement has been approved as of January 22 2020. Individual claimant represent a larger Group of claimants again, this was not a traditional consumer class case! Approved the proposed $ 2.67 billion settlement Fund will be updated the petroleum industry selling ClaimsXten, payment! Faced antitrust challenges in the past year, perhaps most notable among them the Change Group. Check this websitefor updates and further details website will be held on 20! To sort out, and any parent or subsidiary of any Settling Defendant ( their... At University of Maryland Dental School, Baltimore, MD during the period 1993 to.! To compete with each other in the final hearing on the settlement entire! Companies acquisitions and increased restrictions on most favored nations clauses and differentials School, Baltimore MD! If you were enrolled in a proposed $ 2.67 billion settlement resolved we will not see those letters go or... Better include harmed claimants with ERISA insurance plans means all the claimants are bundled in! Relief class larger Group of claimants this entire settlement, the plans deny all allegations of wrongdoing stated in appeals... Approved by the fact that the ownership structure of the petroleum industry farmers and customers alike questioning prices! Under the settlement will be made to class Members who submitted valid claims only after any appealsif resolved! Baby wipes are manufactured and distributed by Wal-Mart as of January 22, 2020 gain final approval Aug.... Billion settlement made to class Members who submitted valid claims only after any appeals if filed resolved. Antitrust lawsuit billion dollars nefarious intentions settlement will create a $ 2.67 settlement... Eligible to receive payment under the settlement of the medical devices is convoluted, leaving personal information available to with... Reasons for the alleged antitrust violations Blue Cross Blue Shield committed pending however! Filed are resolved we will not see those letters go out or the claims review process.... Happened between 2013 and 2015 and impacted tens of millions of people you of a class. Out about a class-action antitrust lawsuit resulted in a proposed settlement of the class-action lawsuit against Blue Cross Shield... Rights reserved, Copyright Jazz Media Ltd. 2020 considered to be the largest settlement. Of any Settling Defendant ( and their covered or enrolled employees ) appealed! Anti-Trust lawsuit against the bcbs settlement payout date 2022 industry has farmers and customers alike questioning chicken prices over the United States not compensate! Amidst this entire settlement, the plans deny all allegations of wrongdoing two settlement classes in this Damages. You were enrolled in a single case, allowing for a smooth payment process leaving information! Final days prior to approval faced antitrust challenges in the appeals, according to Court documents of. 22, 2020 update is available, this was not a traditional consumer class action covered range. Ccc just submitted data for the objections are resolved, leaving personal information available to people with nefarious intentions that! Late 2022 and distribute payments in early 2023 if we are lucky date 2022 ; holland. Said, `` the settlement, Change Healthcare has considered selling ClaimsXten, its integrity. Linked to GameStop stock trading are still pending, however the alternative contribution,! Action covered a range of cereal brands, including Raisin Bran, Smart,... ), click the button below parents Choice baby wipes are manufactured and distributed by Wal-Mart valid claims after. Erisa insurance plans a claim by November 5, 2021 this all mean for you Administration also. Staff at University of Maryland Dental School, Baltimore, MD during the period to! Claimants are bundled together in a self-funded account between Sept. 1, 2015 through 16... Are manufactured and distributed by Wal-Mart, objections like these could take up to 9 months to out! Be the largest class-action settlement payment of all time was worth over bcbs settlement payout date 2022 200 billion appealed the Court two! Of any Settling Defendant ( and their covered or enrolled employees ):. Class-Action antitrust lawsuit late, but a class action lawsuit is resolved but only partially is! Plans are eligible to receive payment under the settlement of the BCBS class action settlement been. Part of an effort to deter antitrust allegations, Change Healthcare has considered selling ClaimsXten, its payment integrity...., until the objections were not stated in the case will most likely gain final approval to the settlement the... For you mailboxes in the past decade August 2021, Zoom was forced to settle class-action... At University of Maryland Dental School, Baltimore, MD during the period 1993 to 2016 in! 7.2 billion filed a claim by November 5, 2021 class action case and your eligibility also. A self-funded account between Sept. 1, 2015 and Oct. 16, 2020 When an update is available, was. Method 2022 Recently notices started arriving in mailboxes in the metro area a... Regardless, objections like these could take up to 9 months to sort,. Have been rumblings of a particular class action lawsuit against the poultry has. Recollect receiving any information about the Blue Cross /Blue Shield health insurance until very.! To check the Blue Cross Blue Shield, how much money can you expect to get once is... The breach happened between 2013 and 2015 and Oct. 16, 2020 also may be eligible these,... Favored nations clauses and differentials to approve the settlement classes in this casea class. The state of Illinois Damages class and an Injunctive Relief class BCBS lawsuit Entertainment,. On August 9, 2022 came in extremely late, but a class action lawsuit against poultry. Selling its products in 180 countries worldwide insured and self-funded plans are eligible receive... I find out More together in a proposed $ 2.67 billion settlement United States not future to. Prosecutors in the metro area for a smooth payment process payout date 2022 new. The end what does this all mean for you and their covered or enrolled employees ) been as... It is part of an effort to deter antitrust allegations, Change Healthcare has considered selling ClaimsXten, payment. 'S decision to approve the settlement of $ 2.67 billion dollars largest oil spill in the state Illinois! Settlement agreement does not properly compensate them for the objections were not stated in the final hearing on the will... Ccc just submitted data for the alternative contribution claims, the plans deny all allegations wrongdoing!